Smokin' Award
Home: return to home page

Criteria: do you have what it takes to win this award?

Winners: check out these smokin' sites!

Railroad Award Sites: other awards that you could win.

Hook & Eye: visit the railroad site sponsoring the Smokin' Award.

Revisions  ' 07  | ' 06  | ' 05  | ' 04  | ' 03  | ' 02  |  2001
Previous Month JAN FEB MAR APR MAY JUN JUL AUG SEP OCT NOV DEC Next Month
Dec. 19, 2001 Thanks to Mikkel Funder for pointing me to a new award, the "Great Site" Award!

Kudos to Western Massachusetts Railroads, for winning the Bronze.

Criteria changes:
  • Current Updates: A top score will be given to sites with a separate "What's New" page, as well as revision dates on every page.

  • Bandwidth Sensitivity: changed best score maximum size from 80k to 100k.
I really liked the engine sound on the Home page, but to cut down the size of the page I decided that it had to go.
Dec. 5, 2001 To conform to the rest of the site, sub-menus have been added to all of the pages in the Railroad Award Sites section.

The Paliz Bay Railway & Navigation Co. Featured Site has been placed on the Discontinued page. The webmaster of the site hopes to bring it back at some time.
Previous Month JAN FEB MAR APR MAY JUN JUL AUG SEP OCT NOV DEC Next Month
Nov. 25, 2001 Congratulations to CHORINA, for winning the Bronze.

I have received no response from Train Exchange Awards so it has been placed on the No Response page.

Amrail.com is no longer alive. Therefore the HEAVY HAULER Web Site Award is now listed as Discontinued.

Model Train Webring code has been added to home page.
Nov. 20, 2001 The Valley Central Railway received an award back in August and has now been added to the Bronze Winners.
Nov. 18, 2001 Award submission has reopened.
Nov. 11, 2001 Congratulate GWR Modeling for winning the Silver, and to the Western New York Railway Historical Society and the 71A Locomotive Group, the new Bronze Winners!
Nov. 5, 2001 I'm sorry to see the passing of the Highball Award, a fine award program. It is now listed on the Discontinued page.

On the brighter side, Roger Gilbert has started a new award program called the Railroad Artists Award. It is listed on the Active award page.
Previous Month JAN FEB MAR APR MAY JUN JUL AUG SEP OCT NOV DEC Next Month
Oct. 26, 2001 Award submission is temporarily closed until the middle or end of November.
Previous Month JAN FEB MAR APR MAY JUN JUL AUG SEP OCT NOV DEC Next Month
Sept. 21, 2001 We are living in troubling times. Patriotic graphics have been added to the home page.
Sept. 9, 2001 Congratulations to Rail Innovations, for winning the Bronze.
Sept. 7, 2001 The Smokin' Award has a new Silver Winner - Train Gifs Station!

Kudos to UK Model Shop Directory, the new Bronze Winner!

A couple of changes were made to the criteria.
  • I have concluded that I can only effectively evaluate sites written in the English language. Therefore, the initial criteria has changed to reflect this.

  • If a site is honored with the Smokin' Award it should be displayed within two (2) weeks of receipt. If I receive no response within that time, the award may be revoked.
To reflect the change above, the Application page has been revised. Some minor layout and verbal changes were added as well.

The color of the revision dates at the bottom of the pages has changed for easier reading.
Sept. 4, 2001 Sharpo's Miniature World is the new Bronze Winner!

Revision dates have been added to every page of this site.
Previous Month JAN FEB MAR APR MAY JUN JUL AUG SEP OCT NOV DEC Next Month
Aug. 2, 2001 See Jim's Model Engineering, a new Bronze Winner!
Previous Month JAN FEB MAR APR MAY JUN JUL AUG SEP OCT NOV DEC Next Month
July 18, 2001 Congratulations to Dave's Trains, Inc., for winning the Bronze.

A 3.5 rating by Award Sites! has been added to the Highball Award.
July 11, 2001 The point description, Current Updates, apply to updates made only to the applicant's website. The description has been reworded to reflect this.
July 9, 2001 Congratulations to Robert's Lionel Trains Layout for winning the Bronze.

A list of Contacts for Trademark Permissions has been added to the © & ® page.

I'm now asking award winners not to resize the Smokin' Award graphic on the Application page.
July 7, 2001 See the new Bronze Winner, Friends of M30272M TPO Group.

I applied to be added to the Model Train Webring, but have gotten no response after waiting a month. Fearing that this webring is no longer maintained I have removed the coding from my home page.

META copyright tags have been updated.
Previous Month JAN FEB MAR APR MAY JUN JUL AUG SEP OCT NOV DEC Next Month
June 27, 2001 The Nene Valley Railway is the new Bronze Winner!

Railroad Award Sites has been updated.
  • Chris Denbow's Golden Rail Award is defunct and placed on the Discontinued page. But he has a new awards program, the Highball Award that is listed on the Active page.

  • I have received no response from Amrail's Heavy Hauler Award or from Heartland Ohio-Rocket Railroad #1 Train Site Award so both have been placed on the No Response page.

  • The Soon to be Active page has been removed.

  • I have found the OneWorld Awardvergabe. This German award appears to be inactive and has been placed on the No Response page.
Decimal points will be added to all whole percentage numbers on the statistics table in the Winners section.
June 23, 2001 Things you may not know about Copyright and Trademark Laws is now linked from the Criteria section as © & ®.

Additional minor text and graphic changes concerning copyright has been made to the Criteria page, the Application page and the © & ® page.

To simplify navigation, the page you link to from the Criteria or Winners sub-menu is highlighted.
June 13, 2001 The statistics table on the Winners page is now built in JavaScript to automate the percentage functions. It looks the same but makes for easier editing.
June 12, 2001 See Steve's Railway Page, a new Bronze Winner!
June 9, 2001 Along with the new domain the Smokin' Award has a new email address: smokin@kvrr.net.

A statistics table has been added to the Winners page.

Congratulations to the South Jersey S Gaugers for winning a Silver!
June 6, 2001 Due to the closure of Railroad Depot's free sites, the Smokin' Award has moved to smokin.kvrr.net.
June 5, 2001 Take a look at our new Bronze Winner, the Summit Shadow Valley Line.
June 3, 2001 The Smokin' Award is back online and I'm catching up on my backlog of nominations.
Previous Month JAN FEB MAR APR MAY JUN JUL AUG SEP OCT NOV DEC Next Month
Apr. 23, 2001 Application is temporarily closed.
Apr. 18, 2001 The Coding Point Description has been revised. A score of 0 will be given to sites that make it difficult to access the html code, such as those implementing a "no right click" script. Since their is no way to protect information on a public website, I feel that disabling the user's right mouse button is more of an inconvenience than a hindrance.

Two new Bronze Winners have been added, iRail and Minitrains.
Apr. 11, 2001 Chris Denbow's Golden Rail Award has been upgraded to a 3.0 rating by Award Sites!
Apr. 7, 2001 The Smokin' Award has become a "Select Member" with a 3.5 rating from Award Sites! A level banner has been added to the Intro page, and a Select Member plague to the Last Word page.

A new Bronze Winner, U.K. Miniature Railways has been added.
Previous Month JAN FEB MAR APR MAY JUN JUL AUG SEP OCT NOV DEC Next Month
Mar. 24, 2001 A new award called the Minitrains Award of Site Excellence has been added to the Railroad Award Sites Active list.
Mar. 13, 2001 New headers have been added to the Apply for Award page. And due to changes made to the rrdepot server, the application form on this page was broken. It is now fixed.

Trademarks have been added to the Smokin' Award and the Railroad Award Sites logos.

A site description or mission statement has been added to the Intro page.
Mar. 12, 2001 The Railmaster's Best Site Award has been modified.
Mar. 5, 2001 Check out Newfoundland Rail Scenes, our new Bronze Winner.
Previous Month JAN FEB MAR APR MAY JUN JUL AUG SEP OCT NOV DEC Next Month
Feb. 27, 2001 The Frames button on the Intro page now shows the correct frame status.

The Golden Rail Award has gotten a facelift.
Feb. 15, 2001 A change has been made to the criteria. Besides Netscape Navigator 4, I was using Netscape 6 to evaluate browser compatibility. I have now found that the majority of Netscape users prefer Netscape Navigator, so I am now testing in version 4.08 of that browser only. Also, I was testing sites in Microsoft Internet Explorer versions 4 and 5. A very small percentage of users are using version 4, so I now test in IE 5.50 only. It will make it easier for me, as well as the applicant, if I only test in the two most popular browsers. Please see Point Descriptions for this change.

I'm wondering how you are finding this site, so I've added that question to the Applications page.

Congratulations to TraiN'ternet for being the first Silver Winner! This site is well on its way on winning the gold.
Feb. 11, 2001 The Winners page will be broken up according to the award. Two more winners - Central California Rails and ebepe's rail world - have been added to the new Bronze Winners page.
Feb. 9, 2001 As with any new site the bugs are being ironed out. It has always been my intention that the minimum points to win the Bronze Smokin' Award were 70, not 71. This has been changed on the Criteria page.

A bad link to the Train Exchange Awards on the Active Sites page has been corrected.
Feb. 4, 2001 Congratulations to Chris Denbow's train Gifs Station for winning the first Smokin' Award. His site can be linked to from the Winners, page.
Feb. 3, 2001 A new page explaining copyright laws titled, "Things you may not know about Copyright Laws," is linked from the Criteria page.
No Previous Month JAN FEB MAR APR MAY JUN JUL AUG SEP OCT NOV DEC Next Month
Jan. 27, 2001 The awards under Resources were split up and put on separate pages. Resources page is now called Railroad Award Sites. The Resources link has been relabeled to Award Sites. A Railroad Award Sites icon is now offered to other award site webmasters to link back to the awards list.
Jan. 20, 2001 The Smokin' Award is open for business!
Jan. 10, 2001 Minor changes made to Resources page.

"Back" links added to Point Descriptions page.

Revisions page added.
Jan. 5, 2001 The Smokin' Award is finally in beta stage. All award site webmasters are asked to make comments.
Sept. 19, 2000 The Smokin' Award ("Coming Soon") is uploaded onto free web space provided by Railroad Depot.

Revisions  ' 07  | ' 06  | ' 05  | ' 04  | ' 03  | ' 02  |  2001
Page Bottom
Page Top
Page Bottom
Page Top
Page Bottom
Page Top
Page Bottom

Page Top

Contact  |  Sitemap  |  Copyright  |  Privacy  |  Revised